September 7
Offensive: Brady Huber, Illinois College
Defensive: Bradley Knoblock, Ripon College
Special Teams: Greg Cross, Illinois College

September 14
Offensive: Matt McCaffrey, Knox College
Defensive: Colt Duncan, Lawrence University
Special Teams: Andy Webb, Illinois College

September 21
Offensive: Mike Nolden, Beloit College
Defensive: Quin Dixon, Beloit College
Special Teams: Kam Sallee, Beloit College

September 28
Offensive: Tanner Matlick, Monmouth College
Defensive: Jordan Remsza, Ripon College
Special Teams: Marcus Maguire, St. Norbert College

October 5
Offensive: Elijah Fort, St. Norbert College
Defensive: Alex Swanson, St. Norbert College
Special Teams: Bradley Cox, Macalester College 

October 12
Offensive: Daniel Brown, Cornell College
Defensive: Bradley Knoblock, Ripon College
Special Teams: Spenser Thompson-Meyers, St. Norbert College

October 19
Offensive: Kyle Burlingame, Carroll University
Defensive: Alec Beatty, Macalester College
Special Teams: Kaleb Whiting, Cornell College

October 26
Offensive: Tanner Matlick, Monmouth College
Co-Defensive: Dinari Ellis, Illinois College
Co-Defensive: Ty Zimmerman, Carroll University
Special Teams: Logan Uyetake, Illinois College

November 2
Offensive: Jagan Cleary, Lake Forest College
Defensive: Sean Chapman, Lake Forest College
Special Teams: Spenser Thompson-Meyers, St. Norbert College

November 9
Co-Offensive: Kevin Jennings, Carroll University
Co-Offensive: Brady Huber, Illinois College
Defensive: Wyatt Veseth, St. Norbert College
Special Teams : Kaleb Whiting, Cornell College

November 16
Offensive: Ryan Butterfield, Lawrence University
Defenisve: Ryan Grandlic, St. Norbert College
Special Teams: Spenser Thompson-Meyers