September 6
Offensive: Joey Valdivia, Lake Forest
Defensive: Austin Ellsworth, Illinois College
Special Teams: Devan Clark, Cornell

September 12
Offensive: Tanner Matlick, Monmouth
Defensive: Matt Barnes, Monmouth
Special Teams: Kam Sallee, Beloit

September 19
Offensive: Danny May, Beloit
Defensive: Tyler Jensen, St. Norbert
Special Teams: Alex Pasiewicz, Lake Forest

September 26
Offensive: Daniel Brown, Cornell
Defensive: D.J. Frank, Monmouth
Special Teams: Terrell Myers, Jr., Lawrence

October 3
Offensive: J.T. Crosby, St. Norbert
Defensive: Tyler Jensen, St. Norbert
Special Teams:  Joey Biel, Monmouth

October 10
Offensive: Samuel Staehling, St. Norbert 
Defensive: Matt Barrett, St. Norbert
Special Teams:  Spenser Thompson-Meyers, St. Norbert

October 17
Offensive: Joey Valdivia, Lake Forest
Defensive: Pat McDonaugh, Lake Forest
Special Teams:  Dalton James, Knox

October 24
Offensive: Joey Valdivia, Lake Forest
Defensive: R.J. Callow, St. Norbert
Special Teams:  Alex Pasiewicz, Lake Forest

October 31
Offensive: Joey Valdivia, Lake Forest
Defensive: Logan Gigl, Monmouth
Special Teams:  Alex Pasiewicz, Lake Forest

November 7
Offensive: Alex Pasiewicz, Lake Forest
Defensive: Ryan Grandlic, St. Norbert
Special Teams:  Garrett Rau, Knox

November 14
Offensive: Daniel Brown, Cornell
Defensive: Lane Barnes, Ripon
Special Teams:  Joey Biel, Monmouth